Skip to content
Ideenjournal

Neither Saint Nor Sinner: Artemisia Gentileschi’s Electrifying Portrait of Magdalene.

A female figure leans her head back. Eyes closed, lips sealed, yet she is alert. Sporting warm cheeks and vermilion lips, her long golden hair reflects the flare from a single candle, bathed in a incandescent glow in an predominantly shadowy space. Her attire ranges from a delicate chemise—slipping off one shoulder to reveal porcelain skin—to a rich gold and violet cloth. Seemingly solitary, oblivious of any onlooker, dwelling in a state of profound freedom.

An Important Institutional First

This subject is Mary Magdalene depicted in ecstasy, crafted in the 1620s by the Italian Baroque artist Gentileschi. Recently acquired by the National Gallery of Art in the U.S. capital, it is set to go on public view from 24 February. This marks the gallery’s maiden purchase of a work by the artist, and expert Letizia Treves has noted that it portrays the saint as “free from remorse and pain”. This is an important distinction, for generations, her representation has been formed not just by biblical text but fabulated and blurred by influential men.

“The most flexible character in Christian art,” as one academic observed.

Examine images of her and you find a reader, orator, follower, and witness; crying at the foot of the crucifix, anointing Christ’s feet, or gazing heavenward—frequently atoning with pearl-like tears and, too often, exposing her chest. Sometimes identified by a jar of ointment or a red robe—unlike the Virgin Mary’s azure—she is commonly known today as a prostitute, despite no biblical passage describing her as such.

The Layers of Interpretation

“Honestly, we do not truly know who she was,” noted the scholar. “Consequently, numerous strata of interpretation have fallen upon her. Her evolution she experiences, both visually but in story, devotionally, theologically, are as much tied to societal views and theological shifts as they are to belief.” So what do we know?

She is mentioned in the Gospels twelve times. Initially, she has evil spirits expelled from her; the rest, she is present at Christ’s crucifixion and is the first witness to see his rising. It is she who spreads the “gospel”. Her sensual and immoral legacy can largely be traced to a homily given in the 500s by Gregory I, who confused her with another Mary and an unnamed sinner who washed Jesus’s feet with her tears.

In lumping them into one, Pope Gregory effectively “created” the penitent prostitute—a myth further elaborated by subsequent theologians and medieval legends. Painters and sculptors followed suit, and in a predominantly non-reading but visually literate society, this proved influential. Her “seven demons” morphed into the “cardinal vices”, establishing her dominant story as one of sexual fall and later salvation—solidified in artistic renderings that still shape perceptions today.

Centuries of Penitence and Objectification

Consider Donatello’s emaciated, wooden figure clasping her hands in penance, to Caravaggio’s seventeenth-century depiction of her drained of life and near death—not to mention Rubens’ partially clothed, possessed saint held aloft by angels. Mary Magdalene has frequently been diminished sexually. Albrecht Dürer’s print presented her demurely, with cascading hair covering her nude body, while another’s interpretation gazes heavenward, with tearful eyes and carefully placed hands exposing her breasts.

It seems, anguish and objectification were the primary poles in her representation: she could act as a cautionary tale against transgression, be the poster girl for repentance, while providing artists a pretext to depict the female form veiled as piety. This “penitent prostitute” trope endured for centuries—so deeply that institutions called “Magdalene asylums” forced women into exploitative labor, systems that shockingly ended just 30 years ago.

A Radical Reimagining

But what if there was another side to her story? Imagine if her tale could be one of enlightenment and transformation, where she was shown as vibrant, joy, and sublimity? Essentially, what if we saw her via the eyes of a female artist?

This is what Artemisia accomplishes. Her Magdalene is not posing for the viewer; she is without tears, not repenting, not shamed, not objectified, and not dictating a moral lesson. Instead, she has rosy cheeks and is, as described, “vibrantly living … in the grip of ecstatic rapture”. An expert remarked that Gentileschi “endows Mary Magdalene with an electrifying vitality”.

“It is an ecstasy painting, but it’s not her instant of repentance. It’s a moment of divine meeting … described at times as if it’s the finest sexual encounter … the most profound ecstasy she could ever have. It’s beautiful, it’s physical, it’s sexual, it’s spiritual. You are raised outside yourself to a superior plane.”

Frequently, when women depict biblical or legendary women, they present them not as passive, guilty, ashamed, or inferior, but as active, multifaceted, and with wills of their own: “Women with a capital ‘Woman’”.

Part of a Broader Cultural Movement

Therefore, while this new Gentileschi may finally be redressing a representational imbalance at the gallery, its importance extends further. It changes not only how we view biblical and archetypal women, but also the understanding of womanhood in general.

This perspective is one the Church in time acknowledged. In 1969, it formally affirmed her official definition as a devoted disciple rather than a penitent sinner. As recently as 2016, the pontiff elevated her status to “the apostle of apostles”, marking a day in July as her feast day. It seems that, while establishments change, perspectives are shifting. This new purchase—portraying a figure free from a male perspective, living for herself, without anguish nor sensationalised—is part of a larger shift towards equality.

The writer

Alexis Mills

Lena ist eine leidenschaftliche Autorin und Kreativcoach, die ihre Ideen aus dem täglichen Leben schöpft und teilt.

Ideenjournal

Type to search articles.